REVIEW METHODOLOGY · PRELAUNCH FRAMEWORK

How SIMERPU separates evidence, reported experience, and analysis.

How SIMERPU separates evidence, reported experience, and analysis.

Our framework distinguishes the source of a claim, records reviewed, analysis, and limitations. Review procedures will be finalized before platform or employer-experience reviews are published.

Our framework distinguishes the source of a claim, records reviewed, analysis, and limitations. Review procedures will be finalized before platform or employer-experience reviews are published.

EVIDENCE & SOURCE IDENTITY

METRIC DEFINITIONS

CLEAR REVIEW LIMITATIONS

01 · IDENTIFY THE EVIDENCE

Who supplied it? What was actually checked?

Who supplied it? What was actually checked?

Evidence origin and the extent of review will be stated. A supplied record is not automatically independent verification, and a single account should not be generalized into a result for everyone.

Evidence origin and the extent of review will be stated. A supplied record is not automatically independent verification, and a single account should not be generalized into a result for everyone.

Provider-reported

Provider-reported

A claim or result supplied by a platform or provider. We identify the source and date, and state what supporting material was available.

A claim or result supplied by a platform or provider. We identify the source and date, and state what supporting material was available.

Employer-reported

Employer-reported

An employer’s account of implementation, use, support, or results. We explain who supplied it, the period covered, and the evidence reviewed.

An employer’s account of implementation, use, support, or results. We explain who supplied it, the period covered, and the evidence reviewed.

Member-reported

Member-reported

An individual’s account of their experience. It is labeled as personal experience, not independently established performance across the covered population.

An individual’s account of their experience. It is labeled as personal experience, not independently established performance across the covered population.

Checked against supplied records

Checked against supplied records

We describe the specific records checked and the actual extent of review. A vendor-provided spreadsheet alone does not establish independently verified results.

We describe the specific records checked and the actual extent of review. A vendor-provided spreadsheet alone does not establish independently verified results.

02 · DEFINE THE METRIC

Every percentage needs its denominator.

Every percentage needs its denominator.

A utilization figure needs a reporting period, population, numerator, denominator, and definition. Compare figures only when those definitions and populations support the comparison.

A utilization figure needs a reporting period, population, numerator, denominator, and definition. Compare figures only when those definitions and populations support the comparison.

Period & population

Period & population

State the reporting dates and who is included. Distinguish employees only from populations including dependents.

State the reporting dates and who is included. Distinguish employees only from populations including dependents.

Numerator

Numerator

Identify what is being counted: registrations, logins, unique patients, completed encounters, repeat visits, or another explicitly defined measure.

Identify what is being counted: registrations, logins, unique patients, completed encounters, repeat visits, or another explicitly defined measure.

Denominator

Denominator

Explain the eligible, enrolled, activated, or other population used as the base. Different bases can produce figures that are not comparable.

Explain the eligible, enrolled, activated, or other population used as the base. Different bases can produce figures that are not comparable.

Definition

Definition

Explain exactly what counts as use and what does not. Unique people and total encounters answer different questions.

Explain exactly what counts as use and what does not. Unique people and total encounters answer different questions.

Utilization alone does not establish care quality, clinical benefit, or return on investment. Those conclusions require evidence that actually supports them.

Utilization alone does not establish care quality, clinical benefit, or return on investment. Those conclusions require evidence that actually supports them.

03 · USE CONSISTENT CRITERIA

Examine the service, the experience, and the reporting.

Examine the service, the experience, and the reporting.

Scope & claims

Scope & claims

Services, covered population, provider claims with dated sources, and the evidence available to examine those claims.

Services, covered population, provider claims with dated sources, and the evidence available to examine those claims.

Enrollment & clinical use

Enrollment & clinical use

Enrollment and activation separate from clinical utilization, with definitions, periods, populations, and supporting records.

Enrollment and activation separate from clinical utilization, with definitions, periods, populations, and supporting records.

Appointment access & continuity

Appointment access & continuity

Access to appointments, follow-up, continuity, and the limits of the available member-experience information.

Access to appointments, follow-up, continuity, and the limits of the available member-experience information.

Support & employer administration

Support & employer administration

Member support, onboarding, employer administrative responsibilities, and the practical work needed to use the service.

Member support, onboarding, employer administrative responsibilities, and the practical work needed to use the service.

Reporting & reported outcomes

Reporting & reported outcomes

What reports contain, how measures are defined, who reported an outcome, and which conclusions the evidence can support.

What reports contain, how measures are defined, who reported an outcome, and which conclusions the evidence can support.

Assessment & accountability

Assessment & accountability

Strengths, limitations, unresolved questions, a provider response when supplied, the reviewer, review date, and relevant business relationships.

Strengths, limitations, unresolved questions, a provider response when supplied, the reviewer, review date, and relevant business relationships.

04 · KEEP THE CONCLUSION IN PROPORTION

“Insufficient evidence” is a useful answer.

“Insufficient evidence” is a useful answer.

Unsupported conclusions should not become ratings, winners, or headline claims. We will separate reported facts, SIMERPU assessments, and personal experiences, and make limitations visible.

Unsupported conclusions should not become ratings, winners, or headline claims. We will separate reported facts, SIMERPU assessments, and personal experiences, and make limitations visible.

Reported facts

Reported facts

Identify the source, dates, definitions, and the actual extent of verification.

Identify the source, dates, definitions, and the actual extent of verification.

SIMERPU assessment

SIMERPU assessment

Explain the reasoning, criteria, and limitations behind an educational assessment.

Explain the reasoning, criteria, and limitations behind an educational assessment.

Personal experience

Personal experience

Attribute the experience accurately and do not treat one account as proof of general performance.

Attribute the experience accurately and do not treat one account as proof of general performance.

05 · DISCLOSE & ALLOW A RESPONSE

The same criteria. Visible relationships.

The same criteria. Visible relationships.

The editorial criteria apply regardless of sponsorship. Any sponsorship and relevant business relationship must be clearly labeled. Providers may submit evidence, respond, and request factual corrections through the moderated process once intake opens.

The editorial criteria apply regardless of sponsorship. Any sponsorship and relevant business relationship must be clearly labeled. Providers may submit evidence, respond, and request factual corrections through the moderated process once intake opens.

Prepare a factual correction.

Identify the review and statement at issue, the proposed correction, the original dated source, and relevant context. Evidence and response intake is being prepared and is not open yet. Confidential material must not become a public attachment.

Read the source. Examine the claim.

Read the source. Examine the claim.

The review library is being prepared. Use this framework to ask stronger questions now, and explore the planned virtual care and employer-experience collections.

The review library is being prepared. Use this framework to ask stronger questions now, and explore the planned virtual care and employer-experience collections.